Thursday, June 26, 2025
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Careers
  • Contact
Newsroom Nigeria
  • Home
  • News
    • Across the Nation
    • Crime Watch
    • Metro
    • Political Arena
  • Politics
  • Opinions
  • Crime and Court
    • Judiciary
  • Business
    • Banking
    • Business and Economy
    • Business Life
No Result
View All Result
Newsroom Nigeria
Home Foreign

Italy Has Failed to Heed Anti-corruption Warnings – Drago Kos

Newsroom Nigeria by Newsroom Nigeria
October 14, 2024
in Foreign, INVESTIGATION/REPORT
Reading Time: 4 mins read
0
SHARES
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

 

Drago Kos, who chaired the OECD’s Working Group on Bribery from 2014 to 2022, calls on the organisation to hold
Italy accountable for its “abject failure” to address anti-corruption concerns following the demise of the OPL 245 case
and the controversial convictions of the former lead prosecutors.
The most recent meeting of the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development’s (OECD) Working Group on
Bribery could be a true test of the body’s fight against international corruption.
In the second week of October, the Working Group on Bribery, which monitors and enforces the OECD’s Anti-Bribery
Convention, held an extremely important meeting. At issue was Italy’s response to a highly critical report by the working
group on Italy’s anti-corruption performance. If the body fails to take measures against Italy, the convention is in jeopardy as
an effective anti-corruption instrument, with profound consequences for businesses in the US and the 45 other signatory
countries. As the initiator and one of the main authors of the convention that prohibits the bribery of foreign public officials in
international business transactions – which President Joe Biden’s administration has publicly committed to enforcing – the
US has a particular responsibility to act at this critical moment.
In 2022, a Working Group on Bribery review concluded that recent Italian judgments in three major corruption cases were
incompatible with the convention. One of these was associated with Shell and Eni’s acquisition of the OPL 245 oil block in
Nigeria. Both parent companies, 15 high-level company executives, and several former intelligence officers and middlemen
were put on trial in Milan for international bribery. Evidence was presented in court to demonstrate the apparent awareness
and personal engagement of the highest-level executives from both companies in the deal. However, all the defendants
were acquitted in March 2021.
The Working Group on Bribery heavily criticised the judgment, expressing serious concerns about the court’s treatment of
circumstantial evidence and the standards of proof required under Italian law for foreign bribery prosecutions. Other anticorruption activists have also raised concerns over conduct in the OPL 245 trial, which is far from normal. They have pointed
to some eyebrow-raising peculiarities, such as: alleged interference in the judicial selection procedure for the trial, resulting
in a choice of judges lacking experience or expertise in corruption (the Working Group was highly critical of the judges’
interpretation of Italy’s laws with respect to the OECD Anti-Bribery Convention); allegations (which were denied) that
defendants’ lawyers obtained inappropriate access to the judges; alleged intimidation of the prosecutors; and an alleged

Related posts

WEST AFRICA MUST TURN DEMOGRAPHIC STRENGTH AND MINERAL WEALTH INTO JOBS AND INDUSTRY, SAYS TINUBU

June 21, 2025

NIGERIA, BENIN SIGN INTEGRATION AGREEMENT AS PRESIDENTS TINUBU, TALON LEAD CALL FOR REGIONAL REFORMS

June 21, 2025

he lead prosecutors in the OPL 245 case were subsequently targeted and subjected to vilification in the Italian media, in
circumstances so strange that they appeared deliberately orchestrated. Once they had been “discredited” by accusations that
they handled the case in a biased and illegal manner, the prosecutors were removed from running the appeal against the
acquittals and replaced by a prosecutor who had no apparent expertise in prosecuting corruption cases. On the first day of
the appeal, the case collapsed in an unprecedented way when the replacement prosecutor immediately withdrew the
appeal. The OPL 245 prosecution in Italy was dead in its tracks without full exhaustion of judicial appeal processes by the
state. (On the week of the latest Working Group on Bribery meetings, a court in Brescia, northern Italy, convicted the two
OPL 245 prosecutors of failing to disclose potentially exculpatory evidence and sentenced them to eight months in prison –
a decision they plan to appeal against.)
The Working Group on Bribery, in its 2022 report, gave Italy two years to address its failings through reforms that included
ending Italian court interpretations of Italy’s foreign bribery offence that are “…incompatible with the [OECD Anti-Bribery]
Convention.” The Working Group also demanded a review and redrafting of Italy’s anti-corruption laws and training sessions
to ensure the judiciary better understands the nature of international corruption. By any credible measure, Italy’s response
seems to be an abject failure: since the 2022 report, cases including the appeal of the OPL 245 trial demonstrate continued
incompatibility with the OECD Anti-Bribery Convention; Italian judicial bodies have denigrated the Working Group on
Bribery; judicial training sessions have criticised the convention; efforts have even been made to weaken Italy’s anticorruption laws; and the prosecution and conviction of the original OPL 245 prosecutors – which could represent a breach of
the convention’s prohibition on political interference in corruption prosecutions – has effectively decapitated the Milan Public
Prosecutor’s Office (which acts as the main anti-corruption unit in Italy). This is the very same office that the Working Group
on Bribery lauded in the 2022 report; one of the OPL 245 prosecutors convicted for his alleged mishandling of the OPL 245
case previously headed the anti-corruption unit.
We are now at a moment of credibility for the OECD Anti-Bribery Convention. Italy has clearly and consciously failed to
respond to the Working Group’s recommendations to bring the country back in line with the convention. A level playing field
no longer exists, to the detriment of all signatory countries including the US. In a world where governments are increasingly
inclined to protect their companies, even in the worst cases of violations of applicable legal norms, such a development may
turn into a real disaster for the basic principles of non-corrupt and fair international business, which the US sought to defend
by launching the idea of the convention following the adoption of the FCPA at the national level.
Therefore, I offer two recommendations. First, the OECD Working Group on Bribery must consider taking measures to hold
Italy responsible for its continuous post-2022 report failings, and it must inquire whether the targeting of the OPL 245
prosecutors constitutes unlawful political interference. Second, in order to ensure justice, I call on the US Department of
Justice to re-open its suspended investigation of the OPL 245 case – it still has jurisdiction to do so.

Copyright © Law Business Research Company Number: 03281866 VAT: GB 160 7529 10

 

ShareTweetSendShareShare
Previous Post

TINUBU WELCOMES THE SAFE RETURN OF THE SUPER EAGLES AND DEMANDS SWIFT JUSTICE AFTER THEIR INHUMAN TREATMENT

Next Post

DETAILED REPORT OF WHAT HAPPENED TO SUPER EAGLES IN LIBYA – OLAJIRE

Related Posts

Foreign

WEST AFRICA MUST TURN DEMOGRAPHIC STRENGTH AND MINERAL WEALTH INTO JOBS AND INDUSTRY, SAYS TINUBU

June 21, 2025
Foreign

NIGERIA, BENIN SIGN INTEGRATION AGREEMENT AS PRESIDENTS TINUBU, TALON LEAD CALL FOR REGIONAL REFORMS

June 21, 2025
Foreign

GLOBAL ECONOMY WILL NOT WAIT FOR WEST AFRICA TO GET ITS ACT TOGETHER – TINUBU TELLS ECOWAS

June 21, 2025
Foreign

Viewpoint: As Trump Trumps Everything in Sight, By Bola BOLAWOLE

February 20, 2025
Foreign

Viewpoint: Beyond the Triumphalism of Trumpism, By Simbo Olorunfemi

February 3, 2025
Foreign

VIEWPOINT: THE OTHER SIDE OF DONALD! By Akaninyene Esiere

February 2, 2025
Next Post

DETAILED REPORT OF WHAT HAPPENED TO SUPER EAGLES IN LIBYA - OLAJIRE

RECOMMENDED NEWS

FIRSTBANK INTRODUCES THE FIRST HUMANOID ROBOT, RESTATE COMMITMENT TO PROVIDING INNOVATIVE FINANCIAL SOLUTIONS

2 years ago

TINUBU APPROVES TENURE EXTENSION FOR COMPTROLLER-GENERAL OF IMMIGRATION 

3 months ago

Queen Elizabeth: US Varsity Distances Self From Uju Anya’s Tweet

3 years ago

EXPOSED: MUDASHIRU OBASA AND HIS LAGOS ‘SMALL LONDON’

3 years ago

FOLLOW US

POPULAR NEWS

  • Troops Foil Deadly Terrorist Attack In Niger State, Lose 17 Soldiers

    Troops Foil Deadly Terrorist Attack In Niger State, Lose 17 Soldiers

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • ADEBAYO HELD ALOFT THE BANNER OF THE UPN, LED BY OBAFEMI AWOLOWO, TINUBU PENS TRIBUTE TO A TRUE STATESMAN

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • TINUBU SIGNS  FOUR TAX BILLS INTO LAW TO TRANSFORM FISCAL, REVENUE FRAMEWORK

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • INEC Receives Applications To Register Obidients People’s Party (OPP), 109 Other Political Parties Registration

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Lagos Assembly Lauds Obasa’s Decade of Progressive Leadership, Proposes Legislative Institute t

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
Newsroom Nigeria

This independent, liberal online news platform aims to inform citizens about important issues. NEWSROOM NIGERIA covers political, business, economic, national, and international news. They are committed to journalism ethics and hold the government accountable.

  • About
  • Advertise
  • Careers
  • Contact

© 2025 Newsroom Nigeria - Designed by Semasir Connect.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
    • Across the Nation
    • Crime Watch
    • Metro
    • Political Arena
  • Politics
  • Opinions
  • Crime and Court
    • Judiciary
  • Business
    • Banking
    • Business and Economy
    • Business Life

© 2025 Newsroom Nigeria - Designed by Semasir Connect.